Ethical challenges facing veterinary professionals in Ireland: results from Policy Delphi with vignette methodology.

Ethics is key to the integrity of the veterinary profession. Despite its importance, there is a lack of applied research on the range of ethical challenges faced by veterinarians. A three round Policy Delphi with vignette methodology was used to record the diversity of views on ethical challenges faced by veterinary professionals in Ireland. Forty experts, comprising veterinary practitioners, inspectors and nurses, accepted to participate. In round 1, twenty vignettes describing a variety of ethically challenging veterinary scenarios were ranked in terms of ethical acceptability, reputational risk and perceived standards of practice. Round 2 aimed at characterising challenges where future policy development or professional guidance was deemed to be needed. In round 3, possible solutions to key challenges were explored. Results suggest that current rules and regulations are insufficient to ensure best veterinary practices and that a collective approach is needed to harness workable solutions for the identified ethical challenges. Challenges pertaining mostly to the food chain seem to require enforcement measures whereas softer measures that promote professional discretion were preferred to address challenges dealing with veterinary clinical services. These findings can support veterinary representative bodies, advisory committees and regulatory authorities in their decision making, policy and regulation.

What do European veterinary codes of conduct actually say and mean? A case study approach.

Codes of Professional Conduct (CPCs) are pivotal instruments of self-regulation, providing the standards to which veterinarians should, and sometimes must, comply. Despite their importance to the training and guidance of veterinary professionals, research is lacking on the scope and emphasis of the requirements set out in veterinary CPCs. This paper provides the first systematic investigation of veterinary CPCs. It relies on a case study approach, combining content and thematic analyses of five purposively selected European CPCs: Federation of Veterinarians of Europe (FVE), Denmark, Ireland, Portugal and the UK. Eight overarching themes were identified, including 'definitions and framing concepts', 'duties to animals', 'duties to clients', 'duties to other professionals', 'duties to competent authorities', 'duties to society', 'professionalism' and 'practice-related issues'. Some differences were observed, which may be indicative of different approaches to the regulation of the veterinary profession in Europe (which is reflected in having a 'code of ethics' or a 'code of conduct'), cultural differences on the status of animals in society, and regulatory bodies' proactivity in adapting to professional needs and to societal changes regarding the status of animals. These findings will contribute to an improved understanding of the roles of CPCs in regulating the veterinary profession in Europe.

Physiological, physical and behavioural changes in dogs (Canis familiaris) when kennelled: testing the validity of stress parameters.

Domestic dogs (Canis familiaris) housed in kennelling establishments are considered at risk of suffering poor welfare. Previous research supporting this hypothesis has typically used cortisol:creatinine ratios (C/Cr) to measure acute and chronic stress in kennelled dogs. However, the value of C/Cr as a welfare indicator has been questioned. This study aimed to test the validity of a range of physiological, physical and behavioural welfare indicators and to establish baseline values reflecting good dog welfare. Measurements were taken from 29 privately-owned dogs (14 males, 15 females), ranging in age and breed, in their own home and in a boarding kennel environment, following a within-subjects, counterbalanced design. Pairwise comparisons revealed that C/Cr and vanillylmandelic acid:creatinine ratios (VMA/Cr) were higher in the kennel than home environment (P=0.003; P=0.01, respectively) and were not associated with differences in movement/exercise between environments. Dogs' surface temperature was lower in kennels (P=0.001) and was not associated with ambient temperature. No association with age, or effects of kennel establishment, kennelling experience, sex or source were found. Dogs were generally more active in kennels, but showed considerable individual variability. C/Cr and 5-HIAA:creatinine ratios (5-HIAA/Cr) were negatively correlated with lip licking in kennels. Baseline values for each parameter are presented. The emotional valence of responses was ambiguous and no definitive evidence was found to suggest that dogs were negatively stressed by kennelling. It was concluded that C/Cr and, particularly, VMA/Cr and surface temperature provide robust indicators of psychological arousal in dogs, while spontaneous behaviour might be better used to facilitate interpretation of physiological and physical data on an individual level.

A guide to defining and implementing protocols for the welfare assessment of laboratory animals: eleventh report of the BVAAWF/FRAME/RSPCA/UFAW Joint Working Group on Refinement.

The refinement of husbandry and procedures to reduce animal suffering and improve welfare is an essential component of humane science. Successful refinement depends upon the ability to assess animal welfare effectively, and detect any signs of pain or distress as rapidly as possible, so that any suffering can be alleviated. This document provides practical guidance on setting up and operating effective protocols for the welfare assessment of animals used in research and testing. It sets out general principles for more objective observation of animals, recognizing and assessing indicators of pain or distress and tailoring these to individual projects. Systems for recording indicators, including score sheets, are reviewed and guidance is set out on determining practical monitoring regimes that are more likely to detect any signs of suffering. This guidance is intended for all staff required to assess or monitor animal welfare, including animal technologists and care staff, veterinarians and scientists. It will also be of use to members of ethics or animal care and use committees. A longer version of this document, with further background information and extra topics including training and information sharing, is available on the Laboratory Animals website.

Vaccines and animal welfare.

Vaccination promotes animal welfare by protecting animal health, but it also has other welfare benefits, e.g. recent investigations have looked at the potential of vaccines in immunoneutering such as immunocastration--a humane alternative to the painful traditional methods. Similarly, vaccination can be used during disease outbreaks as a viable alternative to stamping-out, thus avoiding the welfare problems that on-farm mass slaughter can cause. Protecting animal health through vaccination leads to improved animal welfare, and maintaining good welfare ensures that animals can respond successfully to vaccination (as poor welfare can lead to immunosuppression, which can affect the response to vaccination). It is clear that vaccination has tremendous advantages for animal welfare and although the possible side effects of vaccination can have a negative effect on the welfare of some individual animals, the harm caused by these unwanted effects must be weighed against the undoubted benefits for groups of animals.

Assessing the welfare of genetically altered mice.

In 2003, under the auspices of the main UK funders of biological and biomedical research, a working group was established with a remit to review potential welfare issues for genetically altered (GA) mice, to summarize current practice, and to recommend contemporary best practice for welfare assessments. The working group has produced a report which makes practical recommendations for GA mouse welfare assessment and dissemination of welfare information between establishments using a 'mouse passport'. The report can be found at www.nc3rs.org.uk/GAmice and www.lal.org.uk/gaa and includes templates for the recommended welfare assessment scheme and the mouse passport. An overview is provided below.

Degrees of aversion shown by rats and mice to different concentrations of inhalational anaesthetics.

The distress associated with the induction of anaesthesia with halothane, isoflurane, enflurane and carbon dioxide was investigated in rats and mice by measuring the level of aversion they displayed on exposure to low, medium and high concentrations of these agents. The animals were exposed to each agent in a test chamber containing air or gas mixtures, which they were able to enter and leave at will, and the level of aversion was assessed in terms of the initial withdrawal and total dwelling times in the chamber. Comparisons between the anaesthetic and air-control treatments indicated that concentrations of the agents recommended for the rapid and efficient induction of anaesthesia were associated with some degree of aversion. Carbon dioxide was by far the most aversive gas for both rats and mice, with the least aversive being halothane for rats, and halothane and enflurane for mice. With all the anaesthetics, the level of aversion increased as the concentration increased.

The novel guanylyl cyclase MsGC-I is strongly expressed in higher-order neuropils in the brain of Manduca sexta.

Guanylyl cyclases are usually characterized as being either soluble (sGCs) or receptor (rGCs). We have recently cloned a novel guanylyl cyclase, MsGC-I, from the developing nervous system of the hawkmoth Manduca sexta that cannot be classified as either an sGC or an rGC. MsGC-I shows highest sequence identity with receptor guanylyl cyclases throughout its catalytic and dimerization domains, but does not contain the ligand-binding, transmembrane or kinase-like domains characteristic of receptor guanylyl cyclases. In addition, MsGC-I contains a C-terminal extension of 149 amino acid residues. In this paper, we report the expression of MsGC-I in the adult. Northern blots show that it is expressed preferentially in the nervous system, with high levels in the pharate adult brain and antennae. In the antennae, immunohistochemical analyses show that it is expressed in the cell bodies and dendrites, but not axons, of olfactory receptor neurons. In the brain, it is expressed in a variety of sensory neuropils including the antennal and optic lobes. It is also expressed in structures involved in higher-order processing including the mushroom bodies and central complex. This complicated expression pattern suggests that this novel guanylyl cyclase plays an important role in mediating cyclic GMP levels in the nervous system of Manduca sexta.

Identification of the cellular target for eclosion hormone in the abdominal transverse nerves of the tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta.

The isolated abdominal central nervous system of Manduca sexta undergoes an increase in cyclic GMP (cGMP) when exposed to the insect peptide eclosion hormone (EH) before pupal ecdysis. Previously, cGMP immunocytochemistry revealed that the EH-stimulated increase in cGMP was contained in numerous filamentous processes within the transverse nerve associated with each abdominal ganglion. These processes seemed to be the axons of neurosecretory cells projecting to this neurohemal organ. In the present paper, we now show that the EH-stimulated cGMP is not present in neurosecretory terminals. There is no colocalization of the EH-stimulated cGMP with immunoreactivity of two peptides, known to be present in axons in the transverse nerves. Furthermore, there is no colocalization of EH-stimulated cGMP with the synaptic vesicle protein, synaptotagmin. The neurosecretory axons are localized to a narrow band at the anterior margin of the transverse nerve, whereas the cellular elements showing an EH-stimulated cGMP increase are primarily present in the posterior region. There are two cell types in this region: a granular and a nongranular type. The cGMP immunoreactivity seems to be contained within the nongranular type. During adult development, the cells of the posterior compartment spread in a thin layer between the transverse and dorsal nerves, become positive for myosin immunoreactivity between pupal stages 5 and 8, and seem to form the adult ventral diaphragm muscles. We conclude that the EH-sensitive filaments in the transverse nerves of Manduca are most likely to be intrinsic cells that subsequently develop into the ventral diaphragm muscles of the adult.

Radiofrequency thermal balloon angioplasty in an experimental model of peripheral arterial stenosis.

RATIONALE: To assess the effect of thermal balloon angioplasty on surgically created peripheral arterial stenoses. METHODS: Unilateral femoral arterial stenoses were created in 17 neonatal lambs (Dorset X Suffolk/Mule), using absorbable sutures. Six to 8 weeks later, the stenoses were dilated using either a standard (N=5), or thermal balloon angioplasty (N=9). Immediate angiography, flow and pressure gradient measurements were made to assess the acute result following either procedure. The survivors were followed up for a further period of 4 to 6 weeks, and a terminal angiographic study performed. The thermally treated segments of vessels were removed for qualitative histologic analysis. RESULTS: Thermal angioplasty appeared to be acutely successful in eight of nine animals, compared with one of five successful procedures following standard angioplasty. Higher therapeutic temperatures (> or = 80 degrees C) were associated with vascular complications. At the terminal study, stenoses had recurred in four of six survivors successfully treated with thermal angioplasty. Histologic studies demonstrated non-uniform effects of thermal dilation on the vessel wall, with variable changes ranging from partial or full-thickness tears, fibroblastic or myocyte proliferation, and disorganization of the vessel wall layers. CONCLUSION: Thermal angioplasty appears to be acutely more beneficial compared with standard angioplasty. However there is a significant recurrence of stenoses, and non-uniform changes in the vessel wall.

Neurons involved in nitric oxide-mediated cGMP signaling in the tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta.

Recently, both nitric oxide synthase (NOS), and nitric oxide (NO)-sensitive guanylyl cyclase were cloned in Manduca sexta and implicated in several cellular, developmental, and behavioral processes (Nighorn et al. [1998] J Neurosci 18:7244-7255). However, NO is a highly diffusive gas, and little is known about the range and specificity of its actions on neurons. To begin examining the role of NO as a neurotransmitter in the central nervous system (CNS) of larval Manduca, we have mapped potential NO-producing neurons using fixation-resistant NADPH-diaphorase staining and antisera that recognize a NOS-specific epitope. In addition, to detect NO-responsive neurons, we treated the CNS with NO donors and used antibodies that recognize elevated levels of cyclic 3;,5;-guanosine monophosphate (cGMP). Many potential NO-producing neurons were mapped, including the ventral unpaired median cells and three pairs of lateral cells in each abdominal ganglion. Additional neurons in the dorsal midline of ganglia A5-7 (PM2) appear to express NOS in a segment-specific manner. At the larval-to-pupal transition, this staining pattern changes; the PM2 neurons stain weakly or are undetectable and there is novel expression of NOS in cell 27. In response to NO donors, a small number of neurons produce detectable cGMP accumulation in a segment-specific pattern. These include a pair of posteriodorsally positioned interneurons (IN505) in all the abdominal ganglia, PM2 neurons in A5, and PM1 and PM2 neurons in A7. Hence, PM2 neurons in A5 and A7 are potentially capable of producing and responding to NO. These identified NO-producing and responding neurons provide a tractable model system for studying the dynamics and specificity of NO signaling in the CNS.

Self-consciousness and animal suffering.

Animals with relatively highly developed brains are likely to experience some degree of self-awareness and the ability to think. As well as being interesting in its own right, self-consciousness matters from an ethical point of view, since it can give rise to forms of suffering above and beyond the immediate physical sensations of pain or distress. This article surveys the evidence for animal self-consciousness and its implications for animal welfare.

Refinement of in vivo tests.

It is important, both morally, scientifically and legally, that animal experimentation causes the minimum amount of suffering necessary to achieve the scientific objective. This paper describes an approach that facilitates the recognition and assessment of animal pain and distress through the use of clinical signs. The score sheet system can help to indicate new scientific responses, as well as to determine and to validate humane end points in the safety testing of biological products using animals. Some examples are given.